Monday, 18 November 2013

The Tobacco Directive & E-cigarettes: Trialogue update

Negotiations between the European Parliament and national governments ("trialogues") on the tobacco products directive have begun and several meetings have already taken place. There is a strong desire to try and reach agreement on the tobacco directive during the Lithuanian Presidency, which runs until the end of the year. 
 

National governments are represented by the Lithuanian Presidency and the EP negotiating team is led by the rapporteur Labour MEP Linda McAvan, along with the shadow rapporteurs from the other political groups. The Liberal group is represented by Belgian Liberal MEP Frédérique Ries, co-author along with myself and Chris Davies of amendment 170 on e-cigarettes.
 

After the first trialogue meeting which addressed the issue of e-cigarettes, Frédérique tweeted the following:
 

"#trilogue #ecig: ça va mal, la Présidence lituanienne ne veut rien entendre, RIEN. Pas un geste, aucune volonté! Je bataille contre un mur"

 
(translation: "It's going badly for e-cigs in trialogue, the Lithuanian Presidency doesn't want to listen at all. Not a gesture, no willingness whatsoever! I am fighting against a brick wall")

 
However, along with Frédérique, the centre right (EPP) and Conservative (ECR) shadow rapporteurs, German MEP Karl Heinz Florenz and UK Tory MEP Martin Callanan made it clear that e-cigarettes were a red line for their respective groups. If those three groups (ALDE, EPP and ECR) vote along the same lines, they form a majority in the European Parliament and once an agreement is reached on the tobacco directive, it will have to be approved by the Parliament (a simple yes/no vote).
 

An agreement on the tobacco directive which is not fully supported by three political groups which constitute a majority of MEPs is unwise, and therein lies the hope for sensible regulation of e-cigarettes.
 

Since the July 2013 position of national governments on the tobacco directive, which included an agreement to support medicines regulation for e-cigarettes, the ground has shifted significantly. Not only did the European Parliament clearly vote against medicines regulation, but action at national level has drawn this matter to public and political attention. In addition, there have apparently been complaints to the Lithuanians that they are going too quickly on e-cigs without allowing national governments the chance to consider other options.


The key country right now is France, which is believed to no longer be supportive of the medicines route for e-cigarettes (and was reluctantly supportive previously), although no official change of position has been announced. In France, 100 leading doctors recently sent a letter to the French government asking them to act on this issue and push for sensible regulation. It is thought that if France changes its position on e-cigs, this may lead other countries to do the same.
 

The irony of a Socialist government in France opposing medicines regulation of e-cigs, contrary to the position of the Socialist group in the European Parliament, while a Conservative/Lib Dem coalition government in the UK supports medicines regulation against its own MEPs, is not lost on me!
 

What is needed right now from a UK perspective is to get increasing numbers of Westminster MPs to question the government/MHRA position. Some Liberal Democrat colleagues of mine at Westminster including Norman Lamb MP, the social care minister, Dan Rogerson MP and Lorely Burt MP have been doing this as has Conservative MP Sarah Woolleston, who is a GP.
 

Along with Chris Davies, I will carry on trying to win over LibDem colleagues at Westminster, but this effort needs to be extended to Conservative and Labour MPs too. I would therefore repeat my previous call for concerned individuals to contact their MP to raise this issue (see previous blog: http://rebeccataylormep.blogspot.be/2013/10/e-cigarettes-and-tobacco-directive.html).
 

It would also be worth noting when you contact MPs that the MHRA is still (as of last week; Jeremy Mean spoke at the e-cigarettes summit in London http://e-cigarette-summit.com/) unable to give more than very vague answers to specific questions about how e-cigarettes could be regulated as medicines. This does not fill me with confidence.....
 

The battle for sensible regulation of e-cigs is not yet over and can still be won!

 

 

 

 

39 comments:

  1. Thank you for your hard work on behalf of public health. If only more MPs could vote with their conscience instead of with regard to party, economic and commercial pressures.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Our consumer research confirms that both users of ecigs are grateful for the unweilding ethics of Rebecca Taylor, Chris Davies and a handful of other true parliamentarians. They bring the spotlight of public conscience into the otherwise twilight world of European politics. Consumers are hopeful of a reasonable outcome, based on amendment 170, which ensures that ecigs are safe yet accessible.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. P.S. That was meant to read "both users and producers of ecigs" ! We all know that there are now significant numbers of ecig users ( soon approaching 2m consumers rather that the implied 2! ) At last week's ECIG Summit, Professor Robert West shared his findings that one in six UK smokers and recent ex smokers have already switched to electronic cigarettes.

      Delete
  3. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Francophone vapers are ready to contest any challenge to the European Parliament’s democratic vote and to the interests of public health by unelected institutions (scroll down for English version): http://www.aiduce.fr/malgre-le-soutien-des-professionnels-de-la-sante-la-cigarette-electronique-reste-menacee/

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Rebecca, (and Chris, Frédérique,...) rest assured the Dutch speaking vapers in the newly founded ACVODA (see http://www.acvoda.nl) will join the legal actions of AIDUCE if necessary as they did with the petitions handed to you. Not only is the e-cig at stake but now also the credibility of European democracy. You have the support of millions.

      Delete
  5. Well, I wouldn't count on Mr. Florenz to make more than a token effort to defend the EVP position.

    He firmly believes in the words of his good friend Martina, the Oracle of Heidelberg.

    http://www.e-zigaretten-lexikon.de/2013/07/23/das-orakel-von-heidelberg-verkuendet-nebuloeses-zur-e-zigarette/

    http://www.e-zigaretten-lexikon.de/2013/07/23/der-brave-landmann-karl-heinz-beackert-das-dampfer-feld/

    He faithfully parroted all that slander about e-cigs and vapers to the german yellow press. And his conspicuous "absence" during the vote for AM 170 speaks volumes.

    He may wear the mask of Paul, but inside he still is Saul. I don't think, he'll ever see the light.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Really a great blog with a best thoughts and ideas are shared thanks for sharing such an interesting article.
    E Hookah

    ReplyDelete
  7. I really would like to praise you for writing such a fabulous article
    Thanks for your great information, the contents are quiet interesting.I will be waiting for your next post. E Cigs

    ReplyDelete
  8. canadaecig
    Clued-up post! Your accepted wisdom is great. Thanks for keep me notify. For more information I will be in touch.

    ReplyDelete
  9. Take a closer look what the ‘refill container’ means. It is the same e-liquid in a bottle which has been tested with the device described in the section 2. So this directive will remove quite a lot e-liquids from the market since there is no rules to certify e-liquids only.

    So this is the way they will ban e-cigs. It is just hidden into the directive. Also it is the reason why there is no need to ban 2nd or 3rd generation devices because you cannot find nicotine liquid for those devices anymore.

    ReplyDelete
  10. You blog is eye-catching. I get pleasure from it. Thanks for sharing this beautiful piece of writing with me.
    E Cig Liquid

    ReplyDelete
  11. Really a great blog with a best thoughts and ideas are shared thanks for sharing such an interesting article.
    Vaporizer

    ReplyDelete
  12. Traditional tobacco cigarettes are addictive. Now, there is a safer alternative of these cigarettes. Smokers can try Nicotine Free Electronic Cigarettes to easily quit smoking.

    ReplyDelete
  13. Thanks for this great blog.I appreciate your spirit for public health.

    E cigarette UK

    ReplyDelete
  14. If u worry about public health so you can advice to people who smoke cigarette/Tobacco that replace with electronic hookah or smoke because this is not harm your health.

    ReplyDelete
  15. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  16. Electronic cigarettes are the best and safer products to avoid tobacco

    ReplyDelete
  17. Good work…unique site and interesting too… keep it up…looking forward for more updates.
    Cigarette Electronique

    ReplyDelete
  18. I never ever read such type of info before this was really incredible. turtle ship v2 clone

    ReplyDelete
  19. You wrote a very motivational and inspiring article. Thanks! treatment for post-traumatic stress disorder

    ReplyDelete
  20. Buy online electronic cigarette for your use. You will be able to Discount electronic cigarettes choose from a range of personal vaporizers and e juices. Best electronic cigarette will come at affordable cost.

    ReplyDelete
  21. Buy online electronic cigarette for your use. You will be able to Discount electronic cigarettes choose from a range of personal vaporizers and e juices. Best electronic cigarette will come at affordable cost.

    ReplyDelete
  22. To delve deeply into Cuban Cigars is an exciting adventure. Advancements in Cuban Cigars can be linked to many areas. Remarkably Cuban Cigars is heralded by shopkeepers and investment bankers alike; leading many to state that it is yet to receive proper recognition for laying the foundations of democracy.

    ReplyDelete
  23. Awesome! Thanks for Googling it and putting the list together and sharing it!
    digital agency

    ReplyDelete
  24. Thank you so much for such a great blog.
    e juice

    ReplyDelete
  25. I have been really impressed by going through this awesome blog. atomizer clone

    ReplyDelete
  26. I have been really impressed by going through this awesome blog.The quantity of Discount electronic cigarettes chain-smokers and such specialists in the market are too numerous, but it is also significant to consider the wellbeing point of interpretation and so now comes particular Buy Online Electronic Cigarette variety and widespread ranges of smokes that are entirely Personal Vaporizers safe and protected for the physique and even healthiness system. Consequently try out this combination and impressionwholly Best electronic cigarette permitted and harmless from all wellbeing and supplementary problems.

    ReplyDelete
  27. Excellent post.I want to thank you for this informative read, I really appreciate sharing this great post... anorexia in teens

    ReplyDelete
  28. Nice blog I follow it You also follow this :- The quantity of Discount electronic cigarettes chain-smokers and such specialists in the market are too numerous, but it is also significant to consider the wellbeing point of interpretation and so now comes particular Buy Online Electronic Cigarette variety and widespread ranges of smokes that are entirely Personal Vaporizers safe and protected for the physique and even healthiness system. Consequently try out this combination and impressionwholly Best electronic cigarette permitted and harmless from all wellbeing and supplementary problems.

    ReplyDelete
  29. Fantastic blog its really good quality of product go through this site for more information.
    electronic cigarette
    Thank you
    Sameer Bhatia

    ReplyDelete
  30. Great blog post! I don’t understand how long it will require me to obtain through all of them!
    nemesis mod

    ReplyDelete
  31. Nice to see this Awesome blofg its so informative for me , Electronic cigarettes are battery-powered smoking devices often designed to look and feel like regular cigarettes. For more info- click this link
    e-cigarette seller india
    Thanks
    Sameer Bhatia
    9811361519

    ReplyDelete
  32. Le blog a été absolument fantastique! Grand nombre d'informations qui peuvent être utiles dans certains ou dans l'autre sens. Garder à jour le blog, impatient pour plus de contenu ... Bon travail, continuez comme ça.
    iquide cigarette electronique

    ReplyDelete
  33. I have go through this page and its blog for more follow our blog:-Electronic Vaporizers are really famous for their effects that they impose on any smokers. You can buy the best electronic cigarette and enjoy the way you smoke. You may Buy online electronic Cigarette and then get the different options available. Buy electronic cigarettes and you can steadily forget about your smoking habit and enjoy life utmost without the different hazards of smoking cigarettes.

    ReplyDelete
  34. getting Health & Electronics cigarrates sites site to marketing your sites.depending various follow us on:-It is possible to Buy Electronic Cigarettes at low cost if you can manage to secure some levels of discount. The Electronic Vaporizers Brooklyn has become massively popular for the sole reason that the vaporizing component inside the cigarette is of really high quality. So to purchase the E-Cigarette NY, it is best to search for the most popular Online Electronic Cigarette Store.

    ReplyDelete